Score: 7

"Stick It"

submission: Prelude to the One

date: December 18, 2009

Not bad, not bad.

The action sequences and fight choreography was really good. The balanced chaos and odd movements made this an interesting blend of cartoons and gunfighters. The only really bad thing I think I can point out is the music selection and the lack of sound effects in general. I don't know if that choice was deliberate, but all in all, a more subtle action track would've been better.

With the obvious talent here in this video by the animator, I'd say try to make something more elaborate than just another stick fight video. You've got skill and an eye for it too. Make something different and I garuntee you'll get the goods.

Score: 7

"Pin it up on the fridge!"

submission: Cat Vader

date: December 18, 2009

This whole short took a while to get moving but when it finally got there, it was most impressive. The first minute or so probably could've been cut out entirely but overall I'd say it was charming. I felt like I was watching something my kid whipped up for art class or something. I had to resist the urge to pin this up on the fridge!

The voice acting wasn't bad at all and I was very impressed with the later bits. Some really good stuff here and of course as always, it was extremely cute.

Score: 10

"'Till Nine Do We Part"

submission: Last Meower

date: March 17, 2009

Excellent work on this and a really damn fine sense of cinematic creativity here. This was one of the best music videos I've seen on Newgrounds and I've seen a lot of them. The choice to not show exactly what the cat was pining for at first was a smart and funny move. The pace was perfect as well on the entire short and I can't think of anything wrong with this at all.

Damn good job.

Score: 10

"The Black Cat"

submission: Jackie

date: March 17, 2009

Very nice and well rounded project here. The animation was smooth, the music choice fit well, the character design was top notch, and the story line was extremely clever as well. The virtually silent approach has been taken before but usually the visual images aren't entertaining enough to keep us on our toes. This animated short doesn't go anywhere you expect it to from start to finish.

Great stuff!

Score: 9

"Welcome Back"

submission: Madness Aggregation

date: March 16, 2009

That was a refreshing change from the usual animated carnage by Krinkels. The landscapes, characters, and of course the different pace made this I think the best madness short thus far.

Very nicely done.

Score: 6

"Ribbit"

submission: Frog

date: March 14, 2009

It was cute...that's about it.

Score: 7

"Great Start"

submission: Bellum Letale

date: March 13, 2009

This was your first flash submission to Newgrounds and for a first start, that was very good. It was really static and is dragged on a bit but it was beautifully drawn and you clearly have vision. I look forward to your next submission and hope this has been helpful.

Score: 6

"Party Joke"

submission: Lin's Dick

date: March 11, 2009

This whole thing had the power and force of a party joke I felt. The writing was mediocre, the story had potential I guess but didn't end up that way, the animation was alright, and the voice over was bad.

I hate to be so negative but this just wasn't really worth anything. Better luck next time I suppose.

Score: 9

"Zero Poopity"

submission: Walk in the Woods

date: March 10, 2009

Just one of those things that makes you thrilled to be alive. Never before has an animator used fecal matter to this extent to create one of the best things ever to come from the human race. A full regalia is in order for this masterwork of legendary calibre.

I was being really generous with all that horse shit. Speaking of shit, great work.

Score: 9

"I just do."

submission: A Pokemon Battle Flash

date: March 8, 2009

I have no idea why this entertains me so much. I first saw this way back when it was on the front page after its release and it still makes me laugh. I think maybe it's because it reminds me of when I used to play Magic: The Gathering....like a dumbass!